Revenue assurance and data · Melbourne, Australia

Industrial and compliance review

Nova Consulting tests an employer's pay, rosters and workforce records against modern awards, enterprise agreements, consent orders and enforceable undertakings, and reports what the evidence shows, what it doesn't, and what to fix. HR, industrial relations and legal teams get an independent view they can rely on when the stakes are high, and payroll is set up so the problem doesn't come back.

The problem

  • An order, undertaking or agreement sets out obligations, but the evidence of meeting them is spread across rosters, payroll, HR records and correspondence.
  • Payroll configuration has drifted from the award or agreement over years of changes, and nobody can say by how much.
  • Suspected underpayments or overpayments have no reliable size, so the board is asked to provision for a worst case.
  • Small errors, such as rounding, repeat in every pay run and grow unnoticed for years.
  • Rostering, time and attendance, payroll and HR systems each hold part of the picture, and they don't agree.
  • Findings may be read by employee representatives, a regulator or a tribunal, so overstating them is as risky as understating them.
  • Remediation has been paid once, but the configuration errors that caused it are still there.

Three ways in

Industrial evidence assessment

For HR, industrial relations and legal teams who need to show what has and hasn't been done.

  1. Set out the obligationsThe relevant instruments, orders and agreements worked through with your HR, industrial relations or legal team, and each obligation turned into something that can be tested.
  2. Identify the evidenceFor each obligation, what would show it has been met, and where that evidence lives: rosters, time and attendance, payroll, HR systems or records.
  3. Test from sourceThe source data analysed, not summaries, and each obligation tested against it.
  4. Report what the data can and can't showFor each obligation, whether the evidence supports it, doesn't, or can't answer the question, and why.
  5. Show what to fixWhere the evidence shows a gap, the cause and the practical fix: a process, a system setting or a record-keeping change.

Every conclusion can be traced to the test that produced it and the source data behind it.

Payroll compliance and remediation

  • Pay rules, pay codes and calculations reviewed for every employee type, against the award, agreement or legislation that applies.
  • Leave reviews, including annual leave, alternative days off, long service leave and public holidays.
  • Suspected underpayments and overpayments investigated. Nova often finds overpayments too: the same setup error that underpays one group can overpay another.
  • Liability calculated per employee and per period from actual pay, roster and time data, so the number isn't inflated by overly cautious assumptions.
  • Independent review of another firm's liability method and calculations, before the numbers are relied on.
  • Remediation support: calculations, payments, employee queries and communications for current and former staff, and options for handling overpayments, worked through with your advisers.

Small errors that add up

Some of the costliest problems are too small to notice in a single pay run. Nova tests the full pay data, not a sample, so patterns like these show up:

  • Rounding of hours, rates or leave at one step of a calculation. A cent or a minute per shift looks like nothing, but repeated across every shift, every employee and every pay run for years, it scales.
  • Allowances and regular extras left out of leave and holiday pay where they should be included.
  • Public holidays that fall during leave, paid at the wrong rate or not recognised at all.
  • Shifts that cross midnight, a weekend or a public holiday, where the rate should change partway through the shift.
  • Rostered, recorded and paid time that don't match because each system rounds or records time differently.

Payroll systems, data and testing

  • Systems and integrations: payroll, time and attendance, rostering and HR systems reviewed, along with the links between them.
  • Data cleansing across payroll and HR systems, so every employee record matches.
  • Testing before go-live: test scripts written and run, with parallel pay runs, before payroll changes go live.
  • Training for new pay calculations and processes.
  • Checking tools and dashboards for leave, overtime, night shifts and visa conditions, so you can keep checking after the review.
  • Ongoing validation of pay runs and investigation of issues, reported monthly.

Supporting legally privileged engagements

Nova can work directly with your legal advisers to deliver specialist investigations, financial analysis and advisory services in circumstances where legal professional privilege may apply.

Don't have an employment lawyer? Nova can put you in touch with employment law specialists it knows, so privilege and the legal questions are covered from the start.

How Nova works

  • Honest about limits. A clear statement of what the evidence supports, what it doesn't, and what data is missing.
  • Sensitive by design. What goes in writing is agreed up front, along with what is briefed in person and what stays confidential.
  • Both directions. Underpayments and overpayments are reported alike, so the fix is right for staff and for the business.
  • Fixes that last. Configuration, process and data fixes, plus the tools to keep checking.
A management assessment, not an audit. It gives you an independent, evidence-based view of what is happening and what to fix. It is not an audit or an assurance engagement under Australian auditing and assurance standards, and it is not legal advice. Interpreting an instrument and advising on your legal position is for your lawyers.

Work Nova has done

Nova's team has worked on payroll compliance for many employers with head offices across Australia and New Zealand. One example:

Payroll compliance programme for a large New Zealand employer. Over several years, Nova led a review of pay rules, pay codes and calculations across every employee type, reporting to a steering committee. Nova reviewed the independent liability calculations, supported the payroll changes through scripted testing and parallel runs, and managed remediation queries and payments for current and former staff. A second phase cleansed employee data, improved the links between payroll, rostering and HR systems, and built reporting and checking tools that keep leave and pay costs in view.

Case studies are anonymised and published with each client's agreement.

Frequently asked questions

Is this a payroll compliance review?

It includes one, but it is broader. A payroll review checks that pay matches the award, agreement or legislation. An industrial evidence assessment tests any obligation in an industrial instrument, consent order or enterprise agreement, including obligations that aren't about pay, such as rostering or process requirements.

Will you tell us whether we are compliant?

Nova tells you what the evidence supports, what it doesn't, and where the data can't answer the question. Whether that amounts to compliance is a legal judgement for you and your advisers.

Do you find overpayments as well as underpayments?

Yes, and often. The same configuration errors that underpay one group can overpay another. Nova reports both, so the fix is right in both directions and you can decide with your advisers how to handle any overpayments.

Can you work under our lawyers' direction?

Yes. Nova can work directly with your legal advisers where legal professional privilege may apply. How findings are reported is agreed with your counsel before the work starts.

We don't have an employment lawyer. Can you help?

Nova can put you in touch with employment law specialists it knows, so privilege and the legal questions are covered from the start.

How do you handle confidential material?

What goes in writing is kept separate from what is briefed in person, and what can be shared from what stays confidential. Access is limited to named team members, and data handling is agreed in writing before the work starts.

Is this an audit?

No. It is a management assessment. It gives you an independent, evidence-based view of what is happening and what to fix. It is not an audit or an assurance engagement under Australian auditing and assurance standards, and it is not legal advice.

How much does it cost?

It depends on the size of the organisation and what is in scope. Nova starts with an initial review of your needs, then provides a costed proposal before any work begins.

Do you offer this in New Zealand?

Yes. In New Zealand the same team runs payroll compliance reviews, including Holidays Act 2003 reviews and remediation: see Payroll Compliance Reviews on novaconsulting.co.nz.

Find out what your evidence really shows

Tell the team what you need to be able to show, and to whom. You'll get a clear view of how it can be tested, and what it needs from you.

Talk to the Australian team